Tin Man: Book Review

Beauty in sadness. I can’t think of a more perfect phrase to sum up this book.

Five succinct pages is all it takes to establish the book’s premise. It’s 1950 and Dora is pregnant with the main character, Ellis. She is stuck in a miserable marriage and rebels against her abusive husband, choosing an amateur sunflower painting over a bottle of whisky when she wins a raffle. The painting becomes an important thread throughout the novel.

Time then jumps to 1996, with Ellis in his mid forties, living a lonely, depressing life. For the past five years he has been consumed by the grief of a tragic event.

It is winter. Bleak and cold, like Ellis’s life. But a bike accident necessitates time away from his factory job, giving him the opportunity to take stock of his life. Spring arrives and the warming sun, mother nature and a break from routine finally start him on the healing process.

Then wham. The book delves into Michael’s life (Ellis’s best friend). We have already got to know Michael through Ellis’s story, which makes the second half of the book even more poignant.

It is 1989, in the midst of the AIDS epidemic. Michael witnesses the devastating effects of the disease, knowing there’s a chance he may have contracted it. It’s what he does with his ensuing time – scanning his body for signs of the disease, while coping with the grief of losing a close friend – that makes this section so heartbreaking. He looks back over his life. At the deaths of Ellis’s mother and Mabel (who were surrogate mothers to him), and at his relationship with Ellis, that was almost so much more than just friendship. Skilful and sympathetic writing lightened the reading of such sorrowful events.

Whilst I was totally enamoured with Sarah Winman’s writing style, the lack of quotation marks and speech tags (he said/she said) detracted a little from my overall reading experience. I’ve not found this a problem with other books, so I can’t explain why the approach bothered me in this instance, other than saying I had to re-read certain paragraphs to get the flow of who said what.

I did like the way Ellis’s story was told in third person, whilst Michael’s was in a first person, ‘journal style’. It made Michael’s account so much more intimate and when the point of view reverted to Ellis’s third person at the end, it was almost a relief to step back from the level of intimacy that Michael’s story demanded.

The ending was as short and perfectly formed as the beginning, with the last few paragraphs told from the point of a view of an outsider. It was the split decision made in the presence of that stranger, changing Ellis’s life forever, that stayed with me.

There is so much sadness in this book you almost drown in it. But it is explored in the most moving, soul-searching way.

Just shy of 200 pages, Tin Man is a quick read, but one that will stay with you.


Sunflowers. An important thread throughout the novel and an annual, uplifting feature in my back garden.


14 thoughts on “Tin Man: Book Review

  1. Your garden looks beautiful, Marie! The sunflower is a symbol for St Julie Billiart, the foundress of the Sisters of Notre Dame de Namur. My daughter attended Notre Dame High School for girls and so I buy her lovely sunflower knick knacks as this flower will always hold a special place in her heart. I’m looking for happy books just now, but I might pick this one up.

    “Be like the sunflower that follows every movement of the sun, and keep your eyes always turned towards our good God.” – St. Julie Billiart

    Liked by 2 people

    • Thanks, Michelle. I didn’t know sunflowers were a symbol for St Julie Billart.
      I’ve been growing them for years, charting my children’s growth against them at the turn of every year in photographs, so they hold a special place in my heart too.
      And the birds that land on the giant heads to eat the ripening seeds are just breathtaking.


  2. What a thoughtful and insightful review, Marie. This book sounds really heart wrenching. I don’t enjoy lack of quotations and speech tags, so I would possibly struggle too. But it does sound like it’s worth a read!

    Liked by 1 person

    • Thanks, Kirsty.
      I was reading a blog the other day that said it was beneficial to allow sadness in your life (sad songs, sad movies, sad books etc). Society is so gung-ho on the pursuit of happiness, that sadness is seen as something to be avoided at all costs.
      I don’t know, but I do feel better for having read the book.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s